I finished Veronica Roth's Allegiant the other day and now I'm mad at everyone. I'm mad at Ms. Roth, I'm mad at Shailene Woodley, I'm mad at Miles Teller (which is hard for me, because I love him), I'm mad at whoever directed and will direct the future movies, I'm mad at my mom, I'm just mad, Okay? But not at Theo James because he's too pretty to be mad at.
Before you go any further, you must understand that I will discuss the book in it's entirety so if you haven't read it, don't read this. I hereby absolve myself from your whining if you do not heed this warning.
I should have know when I found out that the author was changing this novel to two voices instead of one that things were going to get shitty. Why do you need two voices if everyone survives?
Quick background for those who haven't and probably now will not read the series, the novels are about (shocker shocker) a dystopian society where all individuals are broken up into five factions: Abnegation; the selfless, Candor; the honest, Erudite; the wicked smart, Amnity; the kind and Dauntless; the brave. In the first novel there is a test that you go through when you turn a certain age and that test determines which faction you will be in. Our heroine, Tris, is born Abnegation but transfers to Dauntless. Where she meets Four, a fellow Abnegation to Dauntless transfer and then they save everyone from dying and being dead. In the second book things start to fall apart, a bit of a war starts, Tris and Four are in love, but then they fight and shit goes down and at the end of the novel we find out that they aren't the only ones left on the earth anymore, like they had been lead to believe. And now it is expected of them to go out beyond the walls of the city. Dun dun duhhhh!
So when Allegiant begins we're caught in a debate between the force in power and Tris & her crew as to whether or not they should leave the city and find these other people. They defy the rules and you start the book thinking that they whole thing is going to be about the fight to get outside the walls but alas it's not. We find out that the entire city is one giant experiment run by what is left of the United States Government in order to correct damaged genes. Which, I will admit, I found geeeeenius! Roth took the series somewhere that can honestly say I never expected.
Also in this novel for the first time we bounce back and forth between chapters in Tris' voice and chapters in Four's voice. Now, after reading 2 entire novels in Tris' first person narrative, it was extremely difficult to not read the sexy, manly, Four's chapters in a 16 year old girls voice for the first few paragraphs. Anyway, once I got over that I did enjoy hearing things from his perspective. However, his personality was not that different from Tris'. Which probably added to the reasoning why I read his parts as a young girl. His language, thought process and temperament was much like Tris' so, I just found it a little bit annoying.
The novel itself is just as well written as the last two, with some shocking developments that I felt could have been further explored. Such as the fact that Tris' mother wasn't born in the city, but instead was born elsewhere, rescued by this government agency and then entered the experiment voluntarily. Also new characters were introduced that drove the story forward, but not dynamically enough for my taste.
I'm probably being overly critical because I absolutely hated the way the novel, and thus the series, ended. Tris, the heroine of the piece and sole narrator of the first two books, is killed while saving the city from yet another tragedy. Then, we're tortured for chapter after chapter of Four's perspective, dealing with being in his head as he grieves for this girl that he loved, this girl that had changed him for the better.
I guess I just don't understand why Tris had to die. Yes, she sacrificed herself, first for her brother and then for the greater good, but the way it all happened just seemed so ridiculous and pointless and I cannot help but feel like, and this is going to garner some very strong feelings from some people, but I cannot help but feel like the author was simply trying to one up the endings of other novels.
At the end of Harry Potter we lose Fred and Lupin and half of Hogwarts. At the end of The Hunger Games we lose Prim and Finnick and it blows.
And I'm not the author, so my opinion counts for a bucket of nuts, but I just do not in any way feel like that is where the story lead. Only because it was so pointless. Yes, Tris sacrifices herself, and yes her brother would never have been brave enough to perform the task that needed to be done, but with all the tight places Tris has found her way out of throughout the series, I just do not believe that she wouldn't be able to make her way out of this one.
Then some could argue that in a lot of those near death experiences, Four was there to "save" her and he wasn't around this time as he was off doing his own hero thing. We'll to that I say "poo poo" because there were plenty of other situations throughout the series where Tris was Four's hero. So I don't think you have a leg to stand on. And if that is a point that Veronica Roth is trying to bury (which I highly doubt she is) then shame on you Veronica, hasn't Stephanie Meyers done enough to damage teenage girls self worth and strength?
I may sound like the Queen of Douchonia, but I honestly feel like Veronica Roth killed her off for shock value and nothing else. To show a sacrifice for the better good? Naaa, everyone else and their mother has died throughout the series (including Tris' mother) so I don't think more sacrifice is needed. Tris was the only one who could have done it? Ok, yeah maybe, but then I go back to my comment about all the other tight spots this tiny bitch has been in.
And all of this comes down to my final argument. In order to complete her task, Tris has to walk through a Death Serum, which she voluntarily does due to her "advance genes." She survives the serum only to be confronted by the "Big Bad Guy" with a gun. Now she's had guns all day long, all day long on her mission she's like "bang bang bang" and all of the sudden, Ooops I've lost all my weaponry? I just don't buy it. And the fact that he's in there at all is completely unnecessary. Oh, and the piece de la resistance? He's in a frickin' wheel chair. Now you tell me that the person that basically saved an entire city, that risked her own life and the lives of the people she loved in order to do what is right, the girl who was able to fight her way into and out of enemy lines multiple times, would not be able to out maneuver a dude in a wheel chair with a gun?
Anyway, you can tell I have a lot of feelings about this. And I actually threw the book on the floor when I finished. Here I'll show you...
Before you go any further, you must understand that I will discuss the book in it's entirety so if you haven't read it, don't read this. I hereby absolve myself from your whining if you do not heed this warning.
I should have know when I found out that the author was changing this novel to two voices instead of one that things were going to get shitty. Why do you need two voices if everyone survives?
Quick background for those who haven't and probably now will not read the series, the novels are about (shocker shocker) a dystopian society where all individuals are broken up into five factions: Abnegation; the selfless, Candor; the honest, Erudite; the wicked smart, Amnity; the kind and Dauntless; the brave. In the first novel there is a test that you go through when you turn a certain age and that test determines which faction you will be in. Our heroine, Tris, is born Abnegation but transfers to Dauntless. Where she meets Four, a fellow Abnegation to Dauntless transfer and then they save everyone from dying and being dead. In the second book things start to fall apart, a bit of a war starts, Tris and Four are in love, but then they fight and shit goes down and at the end of the novel we find out that they aren't the only ones left on the earth anymore, like they had been lead to believe. And now it is expected of them to go out beyond the walls of the city. Dun dun duhhhh!
So when Allegiant begins we're caught in a debate between the force in power and Tris & her crew as to whether or not they should leave the city and find these other people. They defy the rules and you start the book thinking that they whole thing is going to be about the fight to get outside the walls but alas it's not. We find out that the entire city is one giant experiment run by what is left of the United States Government in order to correct damaged genes. Which, I will admit, I found geeeeenius! Roth took the series somewhere that can honestly say I never expected.
Also in this novel for the first time we bounce back and forth between chapters in Tris' voice and chapters in Four's voice. Now, after reading 2 entire novels in Tris' first person narrative, it was extremely difficult to not read the sexy, manly, Four's chapters in a 16 year old girls voice for the first few paragraphs. Anyway, once I got over that I did enjoy hearing things from his perspective. However, his personality was not that different from Tris'. Which probably added to the reasoning why I read his parts as a young girl. His language, thought process and temperament was much like Tris' so, I just found it a little bit annoying.
The novel itself is just as well written as the last two, with some shocking developments that I felt could have been further explored. Such as the fact that Tris' mother wasn't born in the city, but instead was born elsewhere, rescued by this government agency and then entered the experiment voluntarily. Also new characters were introduced that drove the story forward, but not dynamically enough for my taste.
I'm probably being overly critical because I absolutely hated the way the novel, and thus the series, ended. Tris, the heroine of the piece and sole narrator of the first two books, is killed while saving the city from yet another tragedy. Then, we're tortured for chapter after chapter of Four's perspective, dealing with being in his head as he grieves for this girl that he loved, this girl that had changed him for the better.
I guess I just don't understand why Tris had to die. Yes, she sacrificed herself, first for her brother and then for the greater good, but the way it all happened just seemed so ridiculous and pointless and I cannot help but feel like, and this is going to garner some very strong feelings from some people, but I cannot help but feel like the author was simply trying to one up the endings of other novels.
At the end of Harry Potter we lose Fred and Lupin and half of Hogwarts. At the end of The Hunger Games we lose Prim and Finnick and it blows.
And I'm not the author, so my opinion counts for a bucket of nuts, but I just do not in any way feel like that is where the story lead. Only because it was so pointless. Yes, Tris sacrifices herself, and yes her brother would never have been brave enough to perform the task that needed to be done, but with all the tight places Tris has found her way out of throughout the series, I just do not believe that she wouldn't be able to make her way out of this one.
Then some could argue that in a lot of those near death experiences, Four was there to "save" her and he wasn't around this time as he was off doing his own hero thing. We'll to that I say "poo poo" because there were plenty of other situations throughout the series where Tris was Four's hero. So I don't think you have a leg to stand on. And if that is a point that Veronica Roth is trying to bury (which I highly doubt she is) then shame on you Veronica, hasn't Stephanie Meyers done enough to damage teenage girls self worth and strength?
I may sound like the Queen of Douchonia, but I honestly feel like Veronica Roth killed her off for shock value and nothing else. To show a sacrifice for the better good? Naaa, everyone else and their mother has died throughout the series (including Tris' mother) so I don't think more sacrifice is needed. Tris was the only one who could have done it? Ok, yeah maybe, but then I go back to my comment about all the other tight spots this tiny bitch has been in.
And all of this comes down to my final argument. In order to complete her task, Tris has to walk through a Death Serum, which she voluntarily does due to her "advance genes." She survives the serum only to be confronted by the "Big Bad Guy" with a gun. Now she's had guns all day long, all day long on her mission she's like "bang bang bang" and all of the sudden, Ooops I've lost all my weaponry? I just don't buy it. And the fact that he's in there at all is completely unnecessary. Oh, and the piece de la resistance? He's in a frickin' wheel chair. Now you tell me that the person that basically saved an entire city, that risked her own life and the lives of the people she loved in order to do what is right, the girl who was able to fight her way into and out of enemy lines multiple times, would not be able to out maneuver a dude in a wheel chair with a gun?
Anyway, you can tell I have a lot of feelings about this. And I actually threw the book on the floor when I finished. Here I'll show you...
Basically, what I'm trying to say is... Unless you have a really really really really really great reason to kill off your main character at the end of the series (like *cough* JK Rowling *cough* - a situation in which it would have made sense and the divine Ms. Jo found a way around for us, whew!) just don't do it. Do not.
Because when I say that it has made me hate everything, I mean it has really made me hate everything. I thought the movies was great and now I don't know if I have any interest in seeing any of the other ones. Why am I going to invest my time and money in a series where I don't see my investment come back to me in at least some sort of happy ending. (ie: MockingJay. That was no where near Happy Town, but it at least concluded in a way I could get behind. And I even thought Prim's death was pointless, but I can get behind it and understand why. Just like Finnick's, even though we were in love and that one was a little bit more difficult to get over.)
I'm not saying that there needs to be 2.5 kids and picket fences and dinner on the table at night. But you could have given us loyal fans something Veronica! Something!